Anne of Green Gables

If you want to fully experience the heart and soul of Anne Shirley’s journey, the original novel by L. M. Montgomery is the best place to begin. The detailed descriptions of Prince Edward Island’s natural beauty in the book allow readers to paint their own vivid mental images, making Anne’s world come alive in a deeply personal way. The novel delves far more deeply into Anne’s thoughts, dreams, and imaginative escapades, letting you truly connect with her unique spirit and the cast of memorable characters around her. Through Montgomery’s rich prose, readers are immersed in a story of growth, friendship, and healing that unfolds over time, with plenty of humor and pathos along the way. By reading the book, you’ll also have the chance to encounter subplots, characters, and themes that sometimes don’t make it into film adaptations. The original text offers a nuanced, layered exploration of family, community, and belonging that is hard to capture fully on screen. There’s no substitute for the magic Montgomery weaves with her pen.

One of the main differences between the 1985 film adaptation and the original book is the compression and rearrangement of events. The movie streamlines the storyline to fit within its runtime, sometimes combining or omitting scenes, such as certain escapades at Green Gables or moments with minor characters. As a result, viewers experience a faster-paced narrative that occasionally sacrifices depth for brevity. Another notable change is how the movie handles supporting characters. The adaptation often merges or diminishes the roles of certain townsfolk, like Anne’s classmates, neighbors, and even major influences like Mrs. Rachel Lynde. While the book provides a colorful, bustling community life for Anne to interact with, the film focuses more on a select few, sometimes simplifying the broader tapestry of Avonlea society. Anne’s academic rivalries and friendships, especially with characters like Diana Barry and Gilbert Blythe, are reworked in the film for dramatic effect. The portrayal of Anne’s relationship with Marilla and Matthew Cuthbert also develops differently, with some emotional moments accelerated or emphasized to amplify cinematic impact. Additionally, the way Anne’s misadventures unfold—such as the “Diana gets drunk” scene or the “slate breaking”—often deviates in subtle or significant ways from Montgomery’s original timeline and tone. Lastly, the film introduces some original scenes and dialogues that were never present in the novel, mainly to heighten drama or provide closure for the audience. While faithful to the spirit of Anne, the adaptation sometimes modernizes the language or inserts contemporary sensibilities. These creative liberties can delight or disappoint, depending on how strictly one wishes to experience Montgomery’s vision.