The Case of the Howling Dog

1934 • Crime, Mystery

A very nervous man named Cartwright comes into Perry's office to have the neighbor arrested for his howling dog. He states that the howling is a sign that there is a death in the neighborhood. He also wants a will written giving his estate to the lady living at the neighbors house. It is all very mysterious and by the next day, his will is changed and Cartwright is missing, as is the lady of the house next door. Perry has a will and a retainer and must find out whether he has a client or a beneficiary.

Runtime: 1h 14m

Why you should read the novel

If you are a fan of gripping mysteries, reading The Case of the Howling Dog by Erle Stanley Gardner is a must. The novel provides a deeper dive into the complex world of Perry Mason, the iconic defense attorney, offering subtleties and narrative twists that sometimes get lost in film adaptations. Gardner's writing invites readers into the heart of the investigation, allowing you to unravel the clues and motives at your own pace. While the 1934 movie adaptation delivers vintage cinematic suspense, the book offers richer character development and a more intricate plot. The narrative is expertly woven, with layered testimonies and surprising revelations designed to keep readers guessing until the final pages. Experience the original literary form that established Perry Mason as one of literature’s most beloved sleuths. Diving into the source novel means experiencing the full spectrum of Gardner's storytelling genius. Readers benefit from more detailed legal maneuvering, deeper motivations for each character, and an immersive atmosphere that only the written word provides. Discover why millions of readers have cherished Gardner's novels for generations.

Adaptation differences

One significant difference between the 1934 movie adaptation of The Case of the Howling Dog and Erle Stanley Gardner’s original novel is the complexity of the plot. The novel spends more time developing subplots and exploring legal intricacies that the film often simplifies or omits due to time constraints. These richer details in the book create a more compelling and intellectually challenging experience. Characterization is another area that diverges between the book and the movie. In Gardner's novel, Perry Mason’s cunning strategies and unique personality are showcased through expertly written courtroom scenes and internal monologues. The film condenses these traits for a broader audience, resulting in a more straightforward portrayal of Mason compared to his nuanced book counterpart. Additionally, certain secondary characters and plot twists are either altered or removed entirely in the movie. This results in a more streamlined story on film, but it also means that some of the novel’s suspense and intrigue are lost. The relationships between various clients, suspects, and officials are more multifaceted in the book, giving readers a richer mystery to solve. Lastly, the tone and pacing between the two mediums differ considerably. Gardner’s novel maintains a tense and methodical buildup, while the movie shifts to a faster-paced rhythm to maintain screen engagement. Fans of detailed investigation and suspense will find that the original book offers a far more satisfying unraveling of the mystery and legal battle at the story’s core.