The Mallens

Reading the original Mallen novels by Catherine Cookson offers an immersive experience that delves deeply into the minds and motivations of the tortured Mallen family. Cookson’s nuanced and evocative prose brings the bleak Northumberland setting vividly to life, allowing readers to sense firsthand the moors’ chill and the characters’ emotional turmoil. Each chapter provides a richer exploration of generational curses, ambition, love, and tragedy than the screen ever could. The novels offer a broader tapestry of interconnected stories and subplots, fleshing out secondary characters and weaving a complex web of relationships that the TV adaptation condenses. This means that readers get to savor slow-burning developments, intricate character backstories, and moral dilemmas that are only hinted at or simplified in the movie version. Ultimately, by reading Cookson’s books, you gain a fuller appreciation for the historical setting, her sharply drawn characters, and the legacy of secrets and tragedy that haunt the Mallens, making the journey more fulfilling and emotionally resonant than the adaptation allows.

The television adaptation of The Mallens condenses the narrative, merging events from several books into a short series. As a result, entire subplots and some fascinating secondary characters present in the novels are omitted or significantly minimized. While the books take their time to develop the curse of the Mallen streak across multiple generations, the series streamlines these arcs in the interest of pacing and clarity for viewers. Another major difference is the interiority of the characters. Catherine Cookson’s novels provide extensive inner monologues, motivations, and psychological insights, especially into Thomas Mallen’s troubled mind. The adaptation, focused more on dialogue and visual storytelling, cannot fully convey these complexities, so character decisions may seem abrupt or underexplained compared to the books. The TV adaptation also softens or omits several of the novels’ darker themes and events, reducing the bleakness and harsh realism. Choices around violence, fate, and the generational nature of the Mallen curse are presented in a way that is more palatable for a general audience, sometimes leading to altered or less impactful climaxes. Finally, the tone and atmosphere in the books are considerably more brooding, with Cookson lingering on the rural setting’s stark beauty and relentless hardships. This depth is difficult to capture on screen, so the adaptation can feel less intense and atmospheric than the immersive experience readers get from the novels.