Miss S

The Miss Phryne Fisher's Murder Mysteries by Kerry Greenwood offer a richer, more intricate world than any screen adaptation can fully capture. With witty prose, historical details, and the fierce independence of Phryne Fisher, readers can immerse themselves in a 1920s Melbourne authentically interpreted through Greenwood’s sharp observations. The novels provide layers of character backstory and nuanced relationships that unravel deeper than what’s shown onscreen. Reading the books allows you to appreciate Greenwood’s narrative voice, clever humor, and social commentary—elements that may be diluted or lost within a visual retelling. The mysteries themselves are tightly plotted, keeping you engaged while delighting in Phryne’s fearlessness and unconventional approach to solving crime. Each volume stands as both a satisfying whodunit and a vibrant slice of its era. Furthermore, fans can explore the entire series at their own pace, experiencing Phryne’s character development and recurring cast far beyond the events depicted in the adaptation. The literary world of Greenwood’s creation continues to expand in the novels, making every installment a fresh adventure filled with glamour, danger, and heart.

Miss S (2020) transposes the action from Greenwood’s 1920s Melbourne to 1930s Shanghai, introducing a distinctive cultural backdrop and altering the social context surrounding the main characters. While the adaptation draws inspiration from the book series’ central female sleuth, it modifies her persona and background significantly to better resonate with the Shanghai setting and Chinese audiences. Thus, Su Wenli is both an homage to and a reinvention of Phryne Fisher. Many of the stories and cases presented in Miss S are original or heavily reworked versions of plots from the books, resulting in new mysteries and narrative beats that do not exist in Greenwood’s novels. This creative decision ensures that both newcomers and fans encounter fresh material, but it also means key turning points and solutions may be unfamiliar to readers of the source material. The supporting cast and their relationships to the protagonist are also adapted, with character dynamics tailored to fit the new locale and cultural expectations. Certain book characters are omitted, merged, or replaced with counterparts unique to the Shanghai setting, meaning the emotional arcs and character journeys evolve differently. This can lead to distinct motivations and alliances compared to the original series. Visually, Miss S adapts the glamour and style of Phryne Fisher but reimagines it with 1930s Shanghai opulence. The atmosphere, societal norms, and even the moral undertones shift to reflect the adaptation’s new historical and geographical context. While the spirit of adventure and empowerment is maintained, the translation inevitably brings changes in tone and storytelling emphasis, making the viewing experience unique from reading the novels.