Things Heard & Seen

Elizabeth Brundage’s novel All Things Cease to Appear offers far more than a ghost story; it’s a deeply layered literary mystery unraveling secrets in a rural upstate town. In the book, the nuanced narrative unfolds through multiple perspectives, immersing readers in the complex psychology and histories of its characters. Rich prose and evocative details elevate the narrative, providing psychological insight and context often left unexplored in the film adaptation. Reading Brundage’s novel, you’ll discover intricacies and tensions that the film only hints at—grief, marital strain, generational trauma, and the unsettling nature of evil rooted in both the supernatural and the everyday. The book’s slow-burn storytelling allows for gradual suspense and greater empathy with the characters, revealing motivations and moral ambiguities that deepen the haunting. For anyone captivated by atmospheric small-town mysteries or haunted family dramas, All Things Cease to Appear is a rewarding literary experience. The depth and complexity of the novel make it a richer, more thought-provoking journey than watching Things Heard & Seen, encouraging contemplation long after the last page.

One of the main differences between Things Heard & Seen and its source, All Things Cease to Appear, is the narrative scope. The film streamlines the story to focus mainly on Catherine and George Claire’s tumultuous relationship and their haunting, whereas the book provides a broader, multi-perspective narrative. The novel gives significant attention to the Hale family (who previously lived in the house), the Chosen family next door, and the broader community, enriching the haunting’s historical roots. The adaptation simplifies character motivations and psychological depth. In the film, George’s deceit and violence escalate quickly, framing him clearly as the antagonist early on. By contrast, the novel delves more gradually into George’s character, creating ambiguity and a slow unraveling, offering readers a more psychologically intricate portrait. Catherine’s experiences and inner turmoil are also more developed in the book, allowing for greater empathy and complexity. Supernatural elements are more pronounced and visually explicit in the movie, with scenes designed for immediate suspense and shock. The book, however, weaves its ghostly presences subtly, blending them with themes of grief, guilt, and generational trauma. This makes the haunting in the novel feel both more ambiguous and more profound, encouraging readers to question what is real and what is imagined. Lastly, the film’s ending diverges substantially from Brundage’s original conclusion, opting for dramatic visual symbolism and closure. The novel offers a more open, ambiguous ending, reflecting its commitment to moral uncertainty and complexity. This shift alters the story’s overall impact, providing a definitive if more conventional cinematic resolution, whereas the book leaves readers with lingering questions and emotional resonance.