John Carter

The source novel, "A Princess of Mars," offers a captivating and immersive experience that delves far deeper into the world of Barsoom than the movie ever could. Edgar Rice Burroughs carefully constructs a vivid and imaginative Martian society full of intriguing cultures, customs, and creatures. The detailed descriptions and expansive storytelling invite readers to explore every corner of this fascinating planet, making for a rich adventure beyond what is portrayed on the screen. Reading Burroughs' original work allows you to experience the internal journey of John Carter firsthand as he confronts alien worlds, befriends strange allies, and discovers true heroism. The narrative, told from Carter’s own perspective, delivers a sense of wonder and immediacy that personalizes his odyssey in ways a film can only hint at. This makes the story more emotionally engaging and intellectually stimulating, highlighting themes of bravery, love, and adaptation. Furthermore, the novel’s classic pulp style and inventive world-building laid the foundations for much of modern science fiction and fantasy. Many pop culture phenomena—themes, archetypes, and story structures—borrow from Burroughs’ imagination. Reading the book not only offers greater depth and adventure than the film but also connects you to the roots of the genre itself.

One of the most significant differences between the movie and "A Princess of Mars" is the portrayal of John Carter’s character and motivations. In the novel, Carter is a mysterious and almost otherworldly figure from the start, with unexplained longevity and a sense of nobility. The movie, however, adds a more conventional tragic backstory involving the loss of Carter’s family, seeking to ground him emotionally and offer viewers a more accessible, modern hero’s arc. Another notable change is the streamlining and compression of complex Martian societies and politics. The book spends significant time detailing the intricate politics among the Red Martians, Green Martians, and other cultures, giving rich context to Barsoom’s conflicts. The film condenses or omits much of this nuance, focusing instead on a more straightforward good-versus-evil struggle and an accelerated introduction to the various Martian factions. The means by which John Carter arrives on Mars also differ between the two. In Burroughs’ novel, Carter is mysteriously transported after being attacked and left for dead in a cave; the transplantation is mystical and left unexplained, adding to the pulp wonder. The film instead frames his journey more as the result of a teleportation device, providing a pseudo-scientific explanation to appeal to modern audiences’ expectations for sci-fi logic. Lastly, the role of Dejah Thoris is significantly altered in the adaptation. In the book, she is strong-minded and integral to the plot, but her character is more a romantic ideal. The film revises her into a more active, warrior-scientist heroine, aiming to give her more agency and align with contemporary views on female protagonists. These differences collectively represent the filmmakers’ efforts to update and streamline the original story for twenty-first-century moviegoers.