Topper

Topper

1937 • Comedy, Fantasy, RomancePG-13
Madcap couple George and Marion Kerby are killed in an automobile accident. They return as ghosts to try and liven up the regimented lifestyle of their friend and bank president, Cosmo Topper. When Topper starts to live it up, it strains relations with his stuffy wife.
Runtime: 1h 37m

Why you should read the novel

Reading Thorne Smith's 'Topper' offers a far richer and more daring journey into the world of the Kerbys and Cosmo Topper than the 1937 film adaptation can provide. The novel overflows with clever wordplay, racy undertones, and biting social satire that push the boundaries of its era—features that were softened or omitted on screen due to production codes and the era's sensibilities. In the book, Smith's sharp characterizations and psychological insights make for an intimate and subtly subversive exploration of middle-class ennui and the transformative power of mischief. Rather than just watching the antics unfold in a sanitized, visual format, the novel invites you into the internal thoughts and motivations of its protagonist. You'll sympathize much more deeply with Cosmo Topper as he navigates the chaos that Marion and George Kerby bring, gaining a personal understanding of what compels him to abandon his dull conformity for a taste of life and unpredictability. Smith’s humor isn't just situational; it's woven into the very fabric of Cosmo’s timid mind, making the book an immersive, laugh-out-loud experience. By reading 'Topper,' you’ll also discover a world less constrained by Hollywood's censorship of the 1930s. The book’s lively innuendo, mature themes, and honest critique of social norms feel surprisingly fresh today. Smith’s original vision offers an irreverent sensibility that gives his supernatural farce a depth rarely matched by its screen adaptation. For sharp comedy and social commentary that stands the test of time, the novel is an absolute must-read.

Adaptation differences

One primary difference between the 'Topper' novel and its 1937 film adaptation is the tone and style of humor. Thorne Smith’s original book is significantly more risqué, filled with suggestive language, drinking, and rollicking innuendo—elements that the film had to water down to conform to Hollywood's Production Code. While the movie maintains a sense of playful mischief, much of the adult edge and sharp satire present in the novel is lost, resulting in a lighter and more sanitized comedic experience. Another major change is in characterization, particularly that of Cosmo Topper and the ghostly Kerbys. In the book, the Kerbys are unapologetically wild, decadent, and uninhibited, pushing Topper—and the story’s boundaries—well beyond the timid conventions of polite society. The film, however, softens their antics and deepens Marion’s romantic appeal, making her less impulsive and more of a sympathetic figure, as opposed to the almost anarchic glee she displays on the page. Plotwise, the adaptation trims or omits several episodes that carry a greater degree of chaos or scandal in the book. Scenes that involve overt drunkenness, risqué situations, and Tusculum’s (Topper's wife’s) more complex character arc are minimized or rewritten for broader, family-friendly appeal. These omissions result in a narrative that, while entertaining, lacks the layered social critique and subversive spirit of the novel. Finally, the novel offers more introspective detail and emotional depth, granting readers a fuller sense of Topper’s inner transformation and the effects of chaos on his personality. The film, because of runtime and visual storytelling constraints, simplifies this journey, prioritizing slapstick and quick comedic beats over gradual character development. This leaves the screen Topper’s evolution feeling less profound and memorable than the book’s trajectory.

Topper inspired from

Topper
by Thorne Smith